Last updated on October 20th, 2022 at 03:54 pm
Some anglers might already have a Humminbird Piranhamax 4, while others are considering purchasing this fish finder. And then some are still on the fence about what fish finder to buy.
So which is the right one for you? In this blog post, we will compare the features of the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 vs Garmin Striker 4, in order to help make your decision easier.
Picking the right fish finder for you can be a difficult task. Do you want portability or range? How important is screen size to you? And what’s your budget?
If you’re trying to decide between the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 and the Garmin Striker 4, we can help. Both of these fish finders have their pros and cons, but overall we think the Garmin Striker 4 is a better buy. Keep reading to see why.
Piranhamax 4 vs Striker 4 Side By Side Comparison
| Humminbird Piranhamax 4 | Garmin Striker 4 |
 |  |
| Check Price | Check Price |
| Display: 4.3 inch | Display: 3.5 inch |
| Split screen: No | Split screen: Yes |
| Resolution: 272×480 pixel | Resolution: 320×480 pixel |
| Dual-beam Sonar: Yes | Dual-beam Sonar: No |
| Frequencies: 200 to 455 kHz | Frequencies: 50-77-200 kHz |
| Maximum Depth: 600 feet | Maximum Depth: 1,600 feet |
| Fish ID: Yes | Fish ID: Yes |
| GPS: No | GPS: Yes |
| Temperature Sensor: Yes | Temperature Sensor: Yes |
| Speed Sensor: No | Speed Sensor: Yes |
| Include Battery: No | Include Battery: No |
The Difference Between Humminbird Piranhamax 4 vs Garmin Striker 4
There are some important differences between the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 vs Garmin Striker 4, so let’s get right to it.
Screen Size:
As you can see in the image on this page, the Humminbird has a 4.3-inch screen while the Garmin Striker 4 has a 3.5-inch screen. All other things being equal, the larger screen is generally more desirable.
Depth Capability:
The Humminbird can get down to depths of 600 feet while the Garmin works up to a maximum depth of 1,600 feet. Depending on where you fish and what you’re fishing for, this might be a very important difference.
Screen resolution:
The Humminbird has 272×480 pixels of Screen resolution while the Striker 4 has 320×480 pixels. Once again, in a side-by-side comparison, the higher resolution is going to look better.
Transducer Compatibility:
The Humminbird can be paired with a 200 to 455 kHz SmartSonar transducer while the Striker works with 50/200 kHz and 77/200 kHz transducers. As per fish finders, 200 kHz is great enough for anglers.
However, the Garmin Striker 4 gives you the option to add a CHIRP (Comprehensive High-Range Imaging Performance) transducer, which will give you better images and more accurate fish readings.
Split Screen Functionality:
The Striker 4 has split-screen functionality and the ability to split the screen in multiple ways, while the Piranhamax 4 does not have any split-screen functionality. It makes the Striker 4 more desirable than the Piranhamax 4.
As a fish finder reviews website, we’ve tested many fish finders over the years. We really like both of these fish finders and highly recommend each one; but if you’re looking for premium features at an affordable price, the Garmin Striker 4 is definitely a better choice.
Dual Beam Sonar:
Another great feature to compare between Piranhamax 4 vs Striker 4 is the Dual Beam sonar. The Piranhamax 4 comes with dual-beam sonar, which gives you a much more accurate and detailed understanding of what’s going on in the water beneath your boat.
Humminbird comes with Dual Frequency sonar capability, which gives you the ability to track down the structure and bottom composition as well as fish.
Meanwhile, Garmin Striker 4 has ClearVü scanning sonar that allows you to scan out to 1,600 feet.
Ideally, this implies that the transducer transmits two pulses at the same time: one narrow and focused, and one broad with less detail.
CHIRP Sonar:
The Striker 4 has a CHIRP transducer, which improves signal resolution and provides more information and clarity. On the other hand, the Piranhamax 4 uses only dual-beam sonar that offers as much detail as the Striker 4.
Include Fish ID:
The Striker 4 and The Piranhamax 4 are both units that are the same when it comes to fish ID. They show fish icons on the screen that indicate the size and type of fish below your boat.
This can be very helpful in terms of identifying what you’re catching and making sure you’re not wasting your time on a small fish.
Temperature Sensor:
Both models are the same for the temperature reading options, and they are including a transducer with a temperature sensor.
Speed Sensor:
The Striker 4 is great for measuring speed but the Piranhamax doesn’t have this feature. This can be useful if you want to make sure you’re trolling at just the right speeds so it won’t get too fast or slow!
GPS:
This is another important factor to compare these two models. The Garmin Striker 4 has a high-sensitivity GPS receiver, which offers an incredibly fast lock-on and showed accurate results, and marks waypoints.
On the other hand, the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 does not have any GPS options.
Color Display:
Both fish finders have color displays, but the Garmin is sharper and brighter.
Maps:
The Garmin Striker 4 comes with a built-in Waypoint map, while the Humminbird requires you to buy the maps.
Humminbird Piranhamax 4
Specs:
- 4.3-inch screen.
- Dual Beam Sonar Technology.
- Down Imaging
- Up to 600 feet Depth Capability.
- 300 Watts RMS/2400 watts PTP.
- Fish ID Technology.
- Temperature Sensor.
The Humminbird Piranhamax 4 is a great fish finder that offers dual beam sonar, a tilt and swivel mount, and the XNT 9 28 T transducer.
This fish finder is easy to use and has a large 4.3″ color TFT display. The Piranhamax 4 is perfect for anyone who wants an affordable and easy-to-use fishfinder.
Garmin Striker 4
Specs:
- 3.5-inch screen.
- Include GPS With Waypoint Map.
- Include Built-in Flasher.
- Fish ID Technology.
- CHIRP Sonar Transducer.
- Temperature Sensor.
- Speed Sensor.
- Up to 1,600 feet Depth Capability.
The Garmin Striker 4 is a great fish finder that offers a 3.5″ color display, dual beam sonar, and a built-in temperature sensor. The Garmin Striker 4 is easy to use and perfect for anyone who wants an affordable and easy-to-use fishfinder.
With a bright, 3.5-inch glove-friendly color display and a simple menu structure, the Striker 4 will help you catch fish quickly and easily. This fish finder is ideal for ice fishing, kayak fishing, and more.
So, which is the right fish finder for you? The Piranhamax 4 or the Striker 4? Both of these fish finders are great options, but the choice ultimately depends on your needs and preferences.
If you want a fish finder with a large 4.3″ color TFT display, then the Piranhamax 4 is your best option. If you want an affordable fish finder that is easy to use and provides premium-quality features, then the Striker 4 would be a better choice.
Which fish finder do you prefer, the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 or Garmin Striker 4?
I prefer the Garmin Striker 4 because it is easier to use and has a larger screen. Plus, it comes with a built-in GPS receiver and a built-in flasher for ice fishing or vertical jigging which is really handy.
The Humminbird Piranhamax 4 is also a great fish finder, but I think the Garmin Striker 4 is a bit better.
You May Like:
- Best Fish Finder for the Money
- Best Kayak Fish Finder Under $100
- Best Fish Finder Under $200
- Best Fish Finders Under $400
- Best 7 Inch Fish Finder Under $500
- Best Marine GPS And Depth Finder
- Best Fish Finder Under $1500
- Best Fishfinder GPS Combo Under 2000
FAQs:
Does the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 have a transducer?
Yes, the Humminbird Piranhamax 4 does have an XNT 9 28 transducer. The transducer is built into the bottom of the unit and emits an ultrasound beam that helps to detect fish in the water.
Is there anything the Garmin Striker 4 has that the Piranhamax 4 doesn’t?
The Garmin Striker 4 has a built-in flasher, and GPS option, which the Piranhamax 4 does not.
The Garmin Striker 4 is also designed with a bright, color screen that makes it easier to see in direct sunlight. Plus, the Striker 4 offers a water temperature reading so you can determine the best fishing spots.
Does the PiranhaMAX 4 have Down imaging?
The PiranhaMAX 4 has Down Imaging, which lets you see what’s below your boat in stunning detail. You’ll be able to easily identify fish, structures, and vegetation on the bottom.
The Bottom Line:
Overall, we think the Garmin Striker 4 is a better buy than the Humminbird Piranhamax 4. Because It has a 3.5-inch great screen, greater depth capability, and a higher resolution.
It also offers the option to add a CHIRP transducer for even better image quality. If these features are important to you, then the Garmin Striker 4 is the clear winner.
